Homeopathy World Community

Creating Waves of Awareness

George Vithoulkas challenges the Sceptics! (22.2.2010)




As the sceptics have made a website calling it 10.23 http://www.1023.org.uk/ in order to degrade homeopathy, George Vithoulkas is suggesting to them
the following proposal!

I challenge the Sceptics !


Several sceptics in 10:23 anti homeopathy campaign (swallowed in public each one a full bottle of different homeopathic remedies just
to show that there was nothing in them.


I propose to swallow the same content of about 60 tablets but in a different way:
Swallow one tablet every day.


I propose the remedy to be Alumina 200C ( a dilution far beyond the Avogadro number) and I promise them that in the end of 60 days a
considerable number of them (up to 10% or more) will be suffering
with slight to severe constipation.


In homeopathy one bottle or one tablet is considered as one dose only. Most probably they knew this?


The first condition for the participants of this experiment will be to have a good general state of health and a normal stool once a
day.


The second to be brave enough to continue with the experiment till the end of 60 days and not stop with the first signs of constipation.


The third, to be honest enough to report the effect.


I promise you that this experiment will settle the matter once for all.


You need to find 40 sceptics for this experiment. As for the side effect? It will be over within a week or two after stopping the remedy.
If you are real sceptics dare to stay with your convictions and do the
experiment publicly!


George Vithoulkas

Views: 170

Tags: 10:23, George, Vithoulkas, alumina, anti-homeopathy, campaign, experiment, homeopathy, sceptic

Comment by Dr. MAS on February 22, 2010 at 11:39pm
I don't think, it would be appropriate to suggest such a long course of try. Forty People for sixty days ….. ??? It looks homeopathy is too slow to react ;)

No forty people will gather at one place, no one will keep them under observation and no one is FREE to give you time for sixty days trial. It is just like saying my Punjabi language phrase

NA NO MUNN TAIL HO GA AUR NO RADHA NACHAY GEE.

A simple trial is

Take one single dose of phos 1M and repeat for three consecutive days. Coryza will start.

OR

Observe variation in body temperature

Take single dose of camphor 30 and repeat four times after five minutes and note the rise of temperature of your body.

We should not be worry about skeptics’ attitude. They have the right criticize us. What we have to do is not to react unknowingly rather we should improve our system and provide solutions of the points, which they are raising. Their criticism and scientific points are very good for us so that we should work out plant to perform research work and remove the hurdles which homeopathy is facing…..

We must think, Why? In modern countries where is dare need to provide health care facilities to people who are more suffering with so many fatal and incurable diseases but in spite of this great suffering they are not allowing homeopathy at official level? JUST THINK ABOUT IT?

To me, the only reason is that we have not proved our worth as HOMEOPATHIC DOCTOR who can treat and cure diseases on scientific base. It does not mean that there is no cure in homeopathy or we can not treat patients…… No, no…. absolutely not. My point is some fourty years back, in USA some 30 thousand homeopaths or naturopaths were doing practice and today, only 3 thousands (1500 homeopath and 1500 chiropractioners) Do you have the reason? As compared to poor countries like India, Pakistan, bungladesh and srilanka. The number of Homeopaths are increasing day by day. Today in Pakistan 1.5 million registered homeopaths. But role of these homeopaths in country health policy is 1 percent. Why? Again prove your worth.

Keeping in view of the facts, we started educating homeopaths at top level. Diploma to Degree and now Ph.D have been started in homeopathic field. We want to increase the standard of education and research work in homeopathy to prove our worth as homeopath. Each patient, disease and problem will be dealt through scientific reasoning. Now we have 1200 homeopaths who have attained that standard. Government of Pakistan has announced to upgrade the status of these homeopaths and promised to assigned a true role in country health policy….. THE REASON???? The only reason behind is that we should first prove our worth before demand.
Comment by Dr. MAS on February 22, 2010 at 11:49pm
Few patients when they report that after using allopathic medicines for coryza, they have developed complaints of dumping ear due to the dryness of excretion and heavy dose of antibiotics. Then I first use arsenic album. Only two or three doses starts coryza again and clear up the ear canal.
Comment by Dr. Meakin Mittu M.D.(Hom.) on February 23, 2010 at 12:53am
i totally agree with Dr.Mas on his point of proving the self worth and capability to the masses, at place of criticising the critics coz then we both are doing the same.
Comment by Vandana sahay on April 24, 2010 at 2:55am
Dr MAS, the number of people using Homeopathy is increasing in Asia as we have a lot of poor people in those parts and many are not in a position to afford allopathy but then they wouldnt continue if homoepathy wasnt effective! However many do have this impression that Homeopathy works very slowly and not worth trying in severe cases. It does have its place in alternative medicine but i guess homoepaths arent able to earn as much as their other counterparts.
Comment by Vandana sahay on April 24, 2010 at 7:47am
George Vithoulkas,
I do have a suggestion for this experiment that you are suggesting...
Since sceptics are so particular about statistical data, why dont yo go ahead with the study but make sure that no experimenter bias enters the data and how does it matter if the volenteer are normal people or sceptics? If the results of this study are unbiased and stistically valid and reliable, it shouold have value for posterity.

Comment

You need to be a member of Homeopathy World Community to add comments!

Join Homeopathy World Community

© 2014   Created by Debby Bruck.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...